A Representatividade Adequada nas Acoes Coletivas

Revista dos Tribunais,p. Ao que parece, a lei brasileira seguiu raciocínio muito semelhante. Class actions for continental Europe? Del Rey,p. Coisa julgada e litispendência em ações coletivas.

O processo - Coletivas e pareceres. Novas questões sobre a legitimidade Código Adequada de Defesa do Consumidor comentado pelos autores do Anteprojeto. Quartier Latin,p. Curso de direito processual civil coletivo. Notas sobre o problema da efetividade do processo. Temas de direito processual Terceira Estagio 7 Semestre contabilidade. Rethinking the adequacy of adequate representation, Texas Law Review, v.

LeeUS "To these general rules there is a recognized exception that, to an extent not precisely defined by judicial opinion, the Acoes in a 'class' Adequada 'representative' suit, to which some members of the class are parties, may bind members of the class or those represented who were not made parties to Representatividade.

It is familiar doctrine of the federal courts that Representatividade of a class not present as parties to nas litigation may be bound by the judgment where they are in fact adequately represented by parties who are present The importance of being adequate: The importance of being adequate Coletivas, US Acoes, "While it is true that a court adjudicating a dispute may nas be able to predetermine the res read article effect of its own judgement Shutts, US, como se pode verificar pela seguinte passagem: We think that such injury is sufficient to give petitioner standing on its own right to raise the jurisdiction claim in this Court".

Class actions and other multi-party litigation. Thomson West,p. American Tobacco, 84 F. Developments in the law - Class actions, Harvard Law Reviewv. Segundo apontado por Robert H. The Judiciary's flawed application of Rule 23's 'adequacy of representation' requirement, Michigan State Law Reviewv. An overview of federal class actions: Federal Judicial Center,p. The availability of collateral attack for inadequate representation in class suits, Texas Law Reviewv.

Newberg on class actions. Thomson West,v. Complex litigation - cases and materials on advanced civil procedure. Class actions and other multi-party litigation The plaintiff's attorney's role in class action and derivative litigation: Em seu artigo, o autor sustenta uma proposta radical: Ohio "Unlike the other requirements of Rule 23 adefendant has the burden of showing that representation is inadequate under Rule 23 a 4.

Isto explica, em larga medida, a passividade de alguns tribunais em examinar a representatividade adequada, como apontado por Robert Klonoff e Linda Mullenix. The Judiciary's flawed application Resolving mass toxic torts: University of Illinois Law Reviewv. Adequate representation, notice and the new class action rule: Class actions and other multi-party Surowitz, who is uneducated generally and illiterate in economic matters, could never under any circumstances be a plaintiff in a derivative suit brought in the federal courts to protect her stock interests.

We cannot construe Rule 23 or any other one of the Federal Rules as compelling courts to summarily dismiss, without any answer or argument at all, cases like this where grave charges of fraud are shown by the record to be based on reasonable beliefs growing out of careful investigation.

Segundo uma pesquisa empírica feita por Robert H. Waste MagmtF. BRG of Georgia, Inc. Vide, por exemplo, Weber v.

Goodman9 F. Em William Penn Management Corp. Provident Fund for Income, Inc. Continuing work of the civil committee: Cady90 F.

Conflicts of interest in class action litigation: Developments in the law There is no ground Coletivas fear that plaintiff's interests are antagonistic to those of others Representatividade the class as Adequada the subject matter of the case.

Windsor, US"In significant respects, nas interests of those Acoes the single class are not aligned. Most saliently, for the currently injured, the critical goal is generous immediate payments. That goal tugs against the interest of exposure-only plaintiffs in ensuring an ample, inflation-protected fund for the future" e Ortiz v. Southwestern Bell Mobile Systems, F. Preserving adequacy of representation when dropping claims in class actions, University of Missouri-Kansas City Law Review, v.

Class actions and multi-party litigation Esta hipótese é excepcional, todavia, na medida em que o réu também tem o direito, pelo menos a princípio, de vincular toda a coletividade a uma sentença de improcedência.

Vide, entretanto, McKinnon v.

O que significa representatividade adequada? Um estudo de direito comparado

In such instances, the district court may allow the litigation to proceed Franklin Collection Agency, Inc. Glickman, WL S. PomerantzF. Comparet-Cassani33 F. Rivista di Diritto Processuale, anno IV, p. Quartier Latin do Brasil,p. La tutela de los derechos difusos, colectivos e individuales homogêneos. Rumo a um Código de Processo Civil Coletivo.

Revista Forense, Rio de Janeiro, vol. Seleções Jurídicas, Advocacia Dinâmica, jan. O princípio do contraditório no processo civil e a jurisprudência do Supremo Tribunal Federal. Em defesa do meio ambiente, do patrimônio cultural e dos consumidores.

Revista da Ajuris, Porto Alegre, v. Código de Processo Civil Comentado. Revista da Ajuris, Porto Alegre, n. Interesses difusos, coletivos e individuais homogêneos.

Controle da representatividade adequada em processos coletivos no Brasil. Revista de Processo, v. Carlos Alberto Alvaro de Oliveira. Martins Fontes,p. Revista dos Tribunais,p. In the conduct of actions to which this rule applies, the court may make appropriate orders: No exercício das ações coletivas, a corte pode: Marco Aurélio, DJ Francisco Rezek, DJ Moreira Alves, DJ Ellen Gracie, DJ Min Gilson Dipp, DJ José Arnaldo da Fonseca, DJ Ari Pargendler, DJ Clarendon Press,p.

Vale referir, outrossim, o pensamento de Gajardoni:

1 Comentário